SIGI Shareholder/Stockholder Letter Transcript:
2025
ANNUAL
REPORT
100 YEARS
STRONG AND
BUILT FOR
THE FUTURE
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (Nasdaq: SIGI)
is a holding company for 10 property and
casualty insurance companies rated A+
(Superior) by AM Best. Through independent
agents, the insurance companies offer
standard insurance for commercial and
personal risks and specialty insurance
for commercial risks. Selective also offers
flood insurance through the National Flood
Insurance Program s Write Your Own Program.
Selective s unique position as both a leading
insurance group and employer of choice is
widely recognized, with awards and honors
including certification for six consecutive
years as a Great Place to Work and listing in
Forbes Best Midsize Employers.
2026 marks a milestone few companies ever reach:
Selective s 100th year in business. Our leadership
position is built on sustained performance, financial
strength, and disciplined execution driving success
today and into the future.
34th
largest P&C carrier in the United States*
4.9B
of net premiums written in 2025
11.5%
10-year average ROE
95.4%
10-year average Combined Ratio
A+
(Superior) rating by AM Best
*Based on 2024 net premiums written in AM Best s annual list of Top 200 U.S. Property/Casualty Writers
2025 GAAP Financial Highlights
2025
2024
%or Point
Change
Better/(Worse)
$4,866.5
$4,630.0
5%
Combined ratio
97.2%
103.0%
5.8
Underwriting income (loss), after-tax
$107.4
$(104.7)
202%
3.4%
(3.7)%
7.1
$421.2
$362.6
16%
$6.6
$(23)
383%
$11,302.4
$9,651.3
17%
$3.32
$3.31
4.0%
4.0%
13.3%
12.8%
0.5
$5,336.9
$4,861.7
10%
$457.2
$197.8
131%
14.4%
7.0%
7.4%
$450.6
$200.1
125%
Non-GAAP operating return on common equit!J*
14.2%
7.1%
7.1
Operating cash flow as% of net premiums written
25.3%
23.8%
1.5
Total assets
$15,155.7
$13,514.2
12%
Stockholders' equit!J
$3,609.0
$3,120.1
16%
Common stockholders' equit!J
$3,409.0
$2,920.1
17%
Diluted net income available to common stockholders
$7.49
$3.23
132%
Diluted non-GAAP operating income*
$7.38
$3.27
126%
Dividends to common stockholders
$1.57
$1.43
10%
$56.74
$47.99
18%
($ in millions, except per share data)
Insurance Operations
Net premiums written
Return on common equit!J from insurance operations, after-tax
Investments
Net investment income, after-tax
Net realized and unrealized investment (losses) gains, after-tax
Total invested assets
Invested assets per dollar of common stockholders' equit!J
Annual after-tax !Jield on investment portfolio
Return on common equit!J from net investment income, after-tax
Summary Data
Total revenues
Net income available to common stockholders
Return on common equit!J
Non-GAAP operating income*
Per Common Share Data
Book value
AVERAGE ANNUAL RETURN
$40,000
$30,000
SIGI
S&PS00
S&P Prop/Cos
$20,000
$10,000
$0 + - - - - - . - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - , - - - - , - - - - - - . - - - - - , - - - - - - r - - - - - , - - - - - ,
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
*Non-GAAP (U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting
Principles) operating income, non-GAAP
operating income per diluted common share,
and non-GAAP operating return on common
equity are non-GAAP measures. Refer to the
section entitled, "Financial Highlights of Results
for Years Ended December 31, 2025, 2024, and
2023" in Item 7. "Management's Discussion and
Analysis of Financial Conditions and Results of
Operations" in the Company's Annual Report on
Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December
31, 2025 for a reconciliation of the non-GAAP
measures to the equivalent GAAP measures.
2025
2025 ANNUAL REPORT
1
I
TO OUR
STOCKHOLDERS
One hundred years ago, Selective was
founded on a simple belief: insurance should
be personal, rooted in relationships, and
delivered with integrity. A century later,
those principles remain at our core. We
are committed to all our stakeholders customers, distribution partners, employees,
shareholders, and the communities we
support - while building lasting strength
through a disciplined approach that promotes
sustained performance over the long-term.
Last year, we reaffirmed our commitment to returning to
a non-GAAP Operating Return on Equity (ROE) of 12%
or better in 2025, following a challenging 2024. I am
pleased to report that we delivered an ROE of 14.4% and
a non-GAAP Operating ROE of 14.2%. This exceeds our
10-year average Operating ROE of 12.1% and our fiveyear average of 12.5%. While this performance reflects
meaningful progress, we fell short of our long-term
combined ratio target of 95%. Improving underwriting
profitability remains our top priority as we continue to
pursue enduring, profitable, and diversified growth .
8.9%CAGR*
$4
- - I
$49
$1
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
c ompound annual growth rate
2
SELECTIVE
Insurance is a long-term business , especially in casualty
lines where claims may take years to fully develop.
A range of external factors - economic conditions,
social inflation, legal trends , and shifts in customer
behavior - impact the ultimate cost of risk. These
dynamics require continuous portfolio assessment
and disciplined action to safeguard profitability.
We continue to invest in capabilities that promote
profitable growth. Growth levers include diversifying
Standard Commercial Lines, exploring geographic
expansion in Standard Personal Lines, and enhancing
product and distribution capabilities in Excess and
Surplus (E&S) and other specialty lines. We also aim
to return approximately 20% to 25% of earnings to
shareholders through dividends.
Guided by this long-term vision and a strong sense
of urgency , we are committed to making significant
progress across several key organizational priorities:
1. Relentlessly improving upon our fundamentals in
risk selection, pricing , and claims adjudication.
2. Diversifying revenue and income within and across
our three insurance segments.
3. Advancing our use of data and technology including artificial intelligence (Al) - to improve
decision-making and efficiency.
NET PREMIUMS WRITTEN
$5
Our Long-Term Approach
Segment Performance
Standard Commercial Lines
In Standard Commercial Lines , net premiums written
grew 6% compared to last year and we delivered a
98.3% combined ratio, which is nearly six points better
than last year.
We are concentrating on underwriting and pricing
actions to boost our largest segment's performance.
For example, in Commercial Auto, we enhanced
classification accuracy, improved rate adequacy,
launched an updated automobile model with improved
variables, and expanded the roll-out of Compass, our
value-added telematics offering .
We are leveraging our tools, granular insights, and
Standard Personal Lines
differentiated operating model to elevate renewal
retention on our best-performing business while
meaningfully reducing retention on our poorer-
Our combined ratio improved by nearly nine points
in 2025. Overall premiums declined as intended, but
our target business grew 10% as we continued our
performing business through appropriate rating actions.
We expect these mix improvement strategies will
increase profitability.
transition to the mass affluent market. We expect future
growth will come in states where pricing aligns with our
profitability objectives.
Looking ahead, organic growth will remain a key driver
of our value. We see ongoing opportunities to increase
market share through our relationships with distribution
partners and new appointments. We also expect growth
from our continued successful expansion into new
geographies. Since launching the West Region in 2017,
we have entered 14 additional states, with Kansas the
most recent addition in 2025. Efforts are underway to
add Montana and Wyoming in 2026.
Investments
Excess and Surplus Lines
Our E&S Lines segment delivered strong underwriting
performance, achieving an 87.8% combined ratio and 11%
growth in net premiums written compared to last year.
We expanded our distribution channel to enable access
Our investment strategy aims to maximize economic
value by generating stable, risk-adjusted after-tax net
investment income and long-term book value growth.
The portfolio's risk profile remained stable, with an
average credit quality of "A+," duration of 4.1 years, and
risk asset allocation of approximately 10%. After-tax net
investment income was $421 million, up 16% from 2024.
Investment income contributed 13.3% to ROE, up from
12.8% in 2024.
We expect the portfolio's strong embedded book
yield to continue to provide a reliable source of future
investment income.
for our retail agents and continued investing in process
efficiency, product development, and scalability.
COMBINED RATIO
2015
2016
- Reported Combined Ratio
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
Underlying Combined Ratio*
2024
2025
Underlying Combined Ratio excludes catastrophe losses and prior year casualty reserve development
2025 ANNUAL REPORT
3
3/26/2026 Letter Continued (Full PDF)